# 李承鹏：2024年度总结

**URL:** <https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208>\
**Category:** 卮言\
**Created:** [2025 年1 月 1 日 03:22 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208 "2025-01-01T03:22:54Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 10\
**Page:** 2

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![Creative](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/creative/32/116_2.png) [@Creative](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/Creative)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 1 日 09:38 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/21 "2025-01-01T09:38:26Z")

</div>

Based on the provided article, here’s an updated list of factual information regarding the armless man on the Wuhan subway:

**Identification of the Individual:**

- The armless man involved in the incident is Li Fengqiang.
- Li Fengqiang is a former national champion in disabled swimming (50-meter butterfly).
- He won a gold medal and broke a world record at the 2002 National Disabled Swimming Championships in the 100-meter butterfly.
- He also won a gold medal at the World Championships in Argentina in 2002, setting a new world record in the 100-meter butterfly.

**The Subway Incident:**

- The incident occurred on March 18th.
- Li Fengqiang attempted to use the accessible通道 (special通道/无障碍通道 - accessible/special通道) at a Wuhan subway station.
- Subway staff requested he show his disability certificate to verify his eligibility for free passage.
- Li Fengqiang did not have his disability certificate with him.
- Wuhan Metro acknowledged the incident and apologized on March 22nd for the inconvenience and the staff’s improper handling of the situation.

**Li Fengqiang’s Response and Background:**

- Following the incident and the ensuing online discussion, Li Fengqiang started a livestream on March 23rd.
- This led to some online users questioning his motives, suggesting he was using the incident for publicity and to promote livestreaming sales.
- Li Fengqiang denied these allegations, stating his intention was to advocate for better policies for disabled individuals.
- He clarified that the video of the subway incident circulating online was taken by a passerby, not by someone he brought with him.
- Li Fengqiang is the chairman of a swimming facility company in Hubei (湖北智乐游泳设施有限公司).
- He previously owned a swimming training center and a mop factory, both of which employed disabled individuals.
- His current company employs a significant number of disabled people (reportedly 70%).

**Wuhan Metro’s Response:**

- Wuhan Metro issued a public apology on March 22nd.
- They admitted that their staff did not handle the situation appropriately.
- They stated they would continue to improve services for passengers with disabilities.

This updated list incorporates the new information from the article, focusing on verifiable facts and avoiding opinions.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![RuletheWaves](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/rulethewaves/32/29332_2.png) [@RuletheWaves](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/RuletheWaves)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 2 日 01:57 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/22 "2025-01-02T01:57:01Z")

</div>

> [@suen](#):
>
> 时不时也冒出一些惊悚新闻，比如无臂人乘地铁时，工作人员要求其出示证件，证明自己是残疾人。

@Creative 在当前残疾证制度下，根据你列出的事实，工作人员的行为有不妥吗？仅凭这些事实，能够称得上“惊悚新闻”，或者作为论据证明文章试图表达的强烈观点吗？

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![Creative](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/creative/32/116_2.png) [@Creative](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/Creative)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 2 日 01:57 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/23 "2025-01-02T01:57:16Z")

</div>

Here’s a thinking process to answer the question about the appropriateness of the staff’s actions and the “shocking news” label:

1. **Identify the Core Question:** The central question is whether, _given the existing disability certificate system and the facts we’ve established_, the subway staff acted inappropriately. The secondary question is whether the event qualifies as “shocking news” and supports the author’s strong negative viewpoint.

2. **Recall the Established Facts:** Review the factual points previously listed about the incident. Crucially, remember the worker _did_ offer to buy a ticket, and the individual _did_ not have his certificate.

3. **Analyze the Staff’s Actions in the Context of the System:**

4. **Consider the “Shocking News” Label:**

5. **Evaluate its Use as Evidence for the Author’s Strong Viewpoint:**

6. **Formulate a Nuanced Answer:** Avoid a simple “yes” or “no.” Acknowledge the different perspectives and the complexities involved. Address both parts of the question: the appropriateness of the staff’s actions _within the system_ and the justification for the “shocking news” label.

7. **Structure the Answer:**

8. **Refine Language:** Use neutral and objective language when describing the facts. Acknowledge the emotional component of the “shocking news” label without adopting it as your own judgment. Use qualifying language (“arguably,” “can be seen as,” “potentially”) to reflect the complexity of the issue.在当前的残疾证制度下，根据我列出的事实，工作人员的行为 **在制度层面** arguably **没有明显不妥** 。 理由如下：

- **核实身份的必要性：** 地铁提供残疾人免费或优惠乘车的政策，通常需要凭有效的残疾证作为证明。工作人员要求出示证件是履行其职责，以防止非符合条件的人员冒用福利。
- **制度的局限性：** 现行制度下，残疾证是主要的身份识别方式。工作人员依规办事，要求提供证件是执行现有规则。
- **工作人员的补救措施：** 事实表明，工作人员在得知该男子未携带证件后，曾提出可以帮助其购票，这在一定程度上体现了补救措施，并非完全的冷漠拒绝。

然而，仅凭这些事实，将此事称为“惊悚新闻”，并以此作为论据来证明文章试图表达的强烈观点， **是存在争议和过度解读的** ：

**为什么称不上“惊悚新闻”：**

- **并非罕见或极端恶性事件：** 与文章中列举的过劳死、恶性杀人等事件相比，地铁工作人员要求出示证件，即使略显不近人情，也远未达到“惊悚”的程度。
- **存在制度性原因：** 工作人员的行为更多是基于现有制度的执行，而非个人恶意或歧视。这更多是制度层面需要完善的问题，而非令人震惊的个例。

**作为论据证明强烈观点的局限性：**

- **事实解读存在偏差：** 文章将此事直接描述为“工作人员要求其出示证件，证明自己是残疾人”，这种描述带有一定的情绪色彩，暗示工作人员不相信其残疾。而实际情况是，工作人员是要求出示证件以符合免费乘车的规定，两者存在细微但重要的差别。
- **以偏概全的风险：** 将个别事件放大，并以此推导出普遍存在的社会冷漠或制度僵化，存在以偏概全的风险。虽然个别案例可以反映一定的问题，但不能简单地代表整个社会或制度的运行状况。
- **缺乏更深层次的背景信息：** 仅凭“要求出示证件”这一事实，无法全面了解当时的情况，例如工作人员的态度、沟通方式等，这些都可能影响我们对事件的判断。

**总结：**

虽然在现有残疾证制度下，工作人员的行为可能在程序上没有明显不妥，但这并不意味着该事件不值得关注和反思。它暴露了现有制度可能存在的僵化和不便，以及在面对特殊情况时缺乏灵活性的问题。

然而，将此事简单粗暴地归为“惊悚新闻”，并以此作为论据来支撑对社会整体负面评价的强烈观点，是缺乏足够论据支撑且存在过度解读的。 这个事件更适合作为一个引子，引发对现有残疾人保障制度和服务细节的讨论和改进，而非作为一个“令人震惊”的负面案例来煽动情绪。

因此，虽然该事件值得关注，但将其定义为“惊悚新闻”并作为强力论据使用，是值得商榷的。李承鹏的文章可能为了增强其批判性和感染力，在描述时进行了一定的情绪化处理。

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![Hatsune\_miku](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/hatsune_miku/32/4563_2.png) [@Hatsune\_miku](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/Hatsune_miku)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 2 日 11:49 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/24 "2025-01-02T11:49:54Z")

</div>

你能给出第三条路吗？  
没有攻击的意思，单纯好奇你的见解

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![without\_name](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/without_name/32/1777_2.png) [@without\_name](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/without_name)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 2 日 12:30 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/25 "2025-01-02T12:30:34Z")

</div>

他给出了全称性命题，论证义务在他论证不存在否定。

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![without\_name](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/without_name/32/1777_2.png) [@without\_name](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/without_name)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 2 日 12:37 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/26 "2025-01-02T12:37:55Z")

</div>

地铁里，把自己腿折起来假装残疾来乞讨，在地铁里不少吧。一个人，看着“无臂”，却迟迟拿不出应有的残疾证，还有人跟拍。如果是你，你会怎么想？

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![RuletheWaves](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/rulethewaves/32/29332_2.png) [@RuletheWaves](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/RuletheWaves)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 2 日 13:10 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/27 "2025-01-02T13:10:56Z")

</div>

除了模仿，显然还可以选择自己走自己的路。当然具体应该怎么办那我也说不清，但不管怎样这肯定是一个很复杂的问题，绝对不是只有“模仿”  
更别说模仿的前提是模仿对象远比我好（还不是各有优劣，要不然那叫学习借鉴，模仿一般是指全盘的），但是你这么说那可就要开启万恶的比烂大赛了

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![chw](https://forum.rdfzer.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/c/6f9a4e/32.png) [@chw](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/chw)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 3 日 07:21 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/28 "2025-01-03T07:21:21Z")

</div>

> [@suen](#):
>
> 维稳仍那么优秀，北京昌平迅速拆除李自成率起义军进城的雕像，在每条大街都有失业人口的时节，可不能让某个失意人抬头就找到了人生偶像

这个多少有点春秋笔法了，本来就是个改造工程，也是迁移到陕西，给说成这样…

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![cnboy](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/cnboy/32/3289_2.png) [@cnboy](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/cnboy)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 3 日 07:33 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/29 "2025-01-03T07:33:50Z")

</div>

我也挺好奇哪个国家不维稳。

---

<div class="post-metadata">

作者： ![Xuqisi](https://forum.rdfzer.com/user_avatar/forum.rdfzer.com/xuqisi/32/1809_2.png) [@Xuqisi](https://forum.rdfzer.com/u/Xuqisi)\
发布日期： [2025 年1 月 8 日 07:40 UTC](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208/30 "2025-01-08T07:40:19Z")

</div>

只要愿意，黑的也可以说成白的。

在众人苦难之时，自认指清前进方向的明灯，不会有谁觉得该高看他一眼，生活本就不易，说与不说，有何区别。

意欲何为。

[上一页](https://forum.rdfzer.com/t/topic/4208.md?page=1)
