Petition

家长的附中,抑或……
7月16日中午11时,正当同学们焦急的等待着分班结果时,预科部语雀系统里增加了一条《平板智能学习机管理方案(试行)》。起初同学们以为这只是一份待研究的规定。可20日中午,随着易控的更新,原先的锁屏变成了写着“北大附中智能学伴”的页面,原有的诸如“网易有道词典”、“deepseek”等应用不再能打开,就连百度都无法用于查询资料。
诚然,前两年高考,北大附中的总体表现并不良好,蔡力上老师入学讲座时说的“六小强第七”已隐隐朝着第八第九退步。但,发放平板与表现下滑在时间上存在关联并不等同于发放平板导致表现下滑,更不等同于严控平板即可提升成绩。否则,为什么不收回平板回归如街斜对面一样的传统学校呢?
如上文提到的《平板智能学习机管理方案(试行)》所说:“学校统一部署基础教育教学软件,以全面保障同学们基本的学习需求。”又如《北大附中学生手册 电子设备管理制度(第2版)》所说“提升学生信息素养,培养学生自主管理能力和责任承担意识,同时为辅助教师在教学中指导学生规范使用电子设备,促进学习效率和质量提升。”学校发放平板本质是为了保障学习需求、促进学习效率和质量提升、更为了培养自主管理能力。而一台网站采用黑名单、应用策略明显收紧的平板显然无法保障学习需求,更与培养自主管理能力的目标渐行渐远。
需要指出的是,新平板管理策略和保障学习需求,促进学习效率和质量间存在着不可调和的矛盾,而非仅仅依靠“个性化学习”的申请负责制可以弥补的。
其一,网站白名单制度对学生查找资料造成的影响是毁灭性的。且不论连百度这样的搜索引擎都无法访问,即使通过申请允许访问百度,查找资料也是不可能的。譬如,我想查找有关热力学第一定律的有关内容,百度给出的前三页包括如下网站:百度百科、百度文库、大连理工大学学科网站、百度教育、上海交通大学中文主页门户、知乎、作业帮等。对于已有的网站白名单制度,以上网页都是不可能访问的。即使通过申请,将上述网页列入白名单,那依然有着题拍拍、山东大学网站等等。且中文互联网并没有一个权威广泛的知识库,想一次就可以找到权威、可信、且能解答所想问题的网站是不可能的。而查找资料是学习的必要手段,老师可能不清楚、可能回复比较慢。既然我们已经有了一台平板,那直接查找资料何不为更为简易的方法。更何论尚处在高一高二的同学们课程中常见的更需要查找资料的项目制学习呢?
其二,学校已有的易控应用白名单制度已非常严格。学校一直认为:学习才是平板最主要的使用目的,又兼有部分生活需求。因此,学校对于以往的白名单的审查已经很严格,例如支付宝、微信等常见软件均不能使用。既然如此,为什么需要重新“大清洗”,让同学们重新送审自己所需的应用呢?原先平板可用的生活类如网易云音乐等应用不可使用。如果是这是为了让我们专心学习,那学习类如柯林斯词典、GeoGebra(图形计算器)、不背单词、KingDraw(结构式查找器)、豆包为什么也不能使用呢。
诚然,有些家长对学校的平板电脑制度颇有意见,认为学校应该严格管理。我们理解学校承受着压力,但我们需要认识到,平板制度并不是为了招生宣传而存在的,也不仅仅是为了满足教育部的要求而存在的。平板制度以往所有的优点我们不应舍弃,更不该舍弃。的确有同学于平板而沉迷,但我们需要认识到的是,在以往平板较严格的管理和老师记录——分级管控的体系下,真正因平板而影响学习的同学并不多。我们不能因少部分同学的“噎”,而废了全体同学利用平板的“食”。
并非抛弃这少部分同学。但与其让大多数同学论证自己学习的合理性,不如沿用以往规定,对自律不严的学生施以他律的监督,而非对所有的学生套上名为《平板智能学习机管理方案(试行)》的枷锁!
以上,
尊敬的马玉国校长和各位领导,我在此向您请愿:请恢复北大附中原有的平板管理制度。

二零二五年七月二十日夜

Last edited by @without_name 2025-07-22T14:57:26Z

20 Likes

It is not advisable to take a confrontational stance during the adaptive learning period, unless parents lead the charge.

6 Likes

First, you can’t transfer me to another class, second, you can’t punish me (
I plan to first post about Sister Xia, then wait for the little guys to revive before charging the tower.

12 Likes

Want to see prompt

3 Likes

我先删了 :upside_down_face: 前车之鉴

6 Likes

这地方还能有人监视?虽然说也不是完全没有可能

5 Likes

byd he posted with his real name on Moments :face_without_mouth: Now it should be the reckoning phase.

10 Likes

Looking forward to a follow-up, hope it’s not some official directive :saluting_face:

3 Likes

So brave… I’m in awe. I’d even be a bit afraid of getting doxxed if I were to be so bold on Yuque.

1 Like

感动
已有十四名同学在请愿书上签字
本以为有三位同学就是胜利了:sob::sob::sob:

17 Likes

Sign there?

2 Likes

Same here.

2 Likes

It was submitted a long time ago, for that class slot this noon.

2 Likes

Considering this was originally an anonymous forum, signing feels like meeting online friends in person.
I apologize for not soliciting signatures on the forum.
If the school doesn’t reinstate the previous system, I plan to collaborate with first and second-year high school students to write a letter to the school leadership after school starts, and will try to get some parents to share it in parent groups (TBD). I hope everyone can come and support us then!
Anyway, thank you all!

8 Likes

截止今日第二结课下课,我将已征集了13位同学签名(共有15位同学签名,但有2位同学撤回签名)的原件交予韩金阳老师,他表示会向上反馈(并且表示拍照时会将名字打码)

6 Likes

If we revise the petition for improvement, one point is to see what changes the school will make during this period, and another is to add the cancellation of this b** interface. Additionally, include a requirement that whatever solution is adopted, it must be announced sufficiently in advance with clear details, giving students time to migrate and back up data, and to provide feedback.
Mainly, I think the core demand regarding the webpage is not an issue.

6 Likes

取消这个B界面已经写进新请愿书了,但是找每个人都再签一次实在困难。所以并没有去推进(
提前做通知这点我慢慢想想怎么融进去吧(我怕被人觉得太激进了……

1 Like

Thirdly, we understand that the school designed the home screen UI to help students focus on their studies. However, from a results perspective, the home screen forced into landscape mode is not compatible with WeChat Work and Yuque, nor is it suitable for placing the tablet on a book page for comparative reading when checking answers. Furthermore, the various applications that were originally on a single home screen could be used by simply clicking them. After the redesign, they need to be found in specific categories and then clicked, and there might be misunderstandings about the categorization (e.g., WeChat Work being classified under ‘Learning’), leading to operational inconvenience. To my knowledge, the original home screen did not lead to the tablet being used for non-study purposes.

3 Likes

Well, compared to demanding a website, I think hoping for data backup is a relatively mild request, isn’t it? Many people have lost data in just one afternoon.

2 Likes

提前向学生明确具体方案容易让校领导应激我感觉,因为这么说就不只是平板的事情了。我觉得作为具体措施,申请放开一中午一类的来备份数据写进去肯定是没问题的。(这个甚至都不用写请愿书,我觉得直接找韩金阳都行(

1 Like